In a tragic incident, severe turbulence on a Singapore Airlines flight from London to Singapore has claimed the life of a 73-year-old man and injured more than 70 passengers. This incident, occurring on May 20, has raised concerns about the nature of turbulence.
The Incident
Flight SQ321, a Boeing 777-300ER, was ten hours into its journey, cruising at 37,000 feet over Myanmar’s Irrawaddy Basin when it suddenly encountered extreme turbulence. Passengers and crew were thrown around the cabin, with objects such as shoes, iPads, and even hot beverage pots crashing into the ceiling. The severe turbulence caused the aircraft to drop more than 1,800 meters (approximately 5,900 feet) in a matter of seconds.
The turbulence was so intense that it resulted in the death of a 73-year-old British man, Geoff Kitchen, due to a suspected heart condition. Kitchen’s death marks the first fatal incident for Singapore Airlines in 24 years. Additionally, 71 passengers sustained injuries, with six in severe condition, including broken arms and gashes on their heads.
Passenger Accounts
Andrew Davies, a passenger on the flight, recounted the terrifying experience, describing how the plane “just felt like it dropped” and how the cabin was filled with screaming. “It probably only lasted a few seconds, but I remember vividly seeing shoes and iPads and iPhones and cushions and blankets and cutlery and plates and cups flying through the air and crashing to the ceiling,” Davies told CNN. He, along with others, assisted in administering CPR to Kitchen, but unfortunately, their efforts were in vain.
Damage and Emergency Landing
The turbulence caused significant damage to the aircraft’s interior, with overhead compartments smashed open and emergency oxygen masks deployed. The flight crew declared a medical emergency and diverted the plane to Bangkok’s Suvarnabhumi International Airport, where it landed at 3:45 p.m. local time. Emergency responders assisted the injured passengers, and the airline arranged onward flights for those who were not severely injured.
Understanding Turbulence
Turbulence is a common occurrence during flights, caused by various atmospheric conditions. Near airports, strong winds can cause turbulence during takeoff and landing. At cruising altitudes, planes can encounter turbulence from storm clouds, mountain airflows, and jet streams. Severe turbulence, like the one experienced on flight SQ321, can be particularly dangerous, turning passengers and objects into projectiles if they are not secured or passengers strapped with their seatbelts.
Atmospheric researcher Paul Williams from Reading University explains that severe turbulence is akin to being on a rollercoaster without restraints, emphasizing the importance of wearing seat belts at all times. He adds that the Singapore Airlines flight might have encountered clear-air turbulence, which is difficult to detect as it occurs outside of clouds and is invisible to radar.
Technological Solutions and Future Predictions
While pilots use turbulence projections and radar to avoid known turbulence areas, clear-air turbulence remains challenging to predict. LiDAR technology, which uses light to detect atmospheric changes, shows promise in identifying such turbulence. However, it is currently expensive and requires further development before it can be widely implemented.
Many relate climate change as the expected culprit attributed to exacerbated turbulence incidents. Research may suggest that as global temperatures rise, jet streams are becoming stronger, leading to more frequent and severe turbulence. A study by Williams and his colleagues found significant increases in clear-air turbulence over the North Atlantic from 1979 to 2020, a trend they claimed is attributed to climate change.
Turbulence and Climate Change
In recent years, the narrative linking turbulence to climate change has gained traction. This argument posits that climate change, by altering atmospheric conditions, is increasing both the frequency and severity of turbulence experienced during flights. However, this claim warrants a critical examination of the scientific evidence and the complex nature of atmospheric phenomena.
Turbulence is essentially chaotic air movement that can jolt an aircraft unexpectedly. The most common types of turbulence are:
- Clear Air Turbulence (CAT): Occurs at high altitudes in clear skies, often near jet streams.
- Mechanical Turbulence: Caused by obstructions like mountains or buildings disrupting the airflow.
- Thermal Turbulence: Results from the rising of warm air and falling of cooler air.
- Frontal Turbulence:** Associated with weather fronts and storms.
Proponents of the climate change-turbulence link argue that global warming is altering wind patterns and strengthening jet streams, thereby increasing the incidence of turbulence, particularly CAT. Studies like those from the University of Reading suggest a potential increase in CAT due to a warmer atmosphere.
Scrutinizing the Evidence
Natural Variability: Turbulence is influenced by a multitude of atmospheric factors that are naturally variable. The atmosphere is inherently chaotic, and attributing changes in turbulence patterns solely to climate change oversimplifies this complexity.
Historical Data Limitations: Long-term data on turbulence is limited, and attributing recent patterns to climate change requires a more robust historical context. Turbulence data collection methods have also evolved, complicating direct comparisons over decades.
Jet Stream Dynamics: Jet streams are influenced by temperature gradients between the equator and poles. While climate change, if any at all, impacts these gradients, the relationship is not straightforward. Some studies indicate that while the polar jet stream is shifting, the overall effect on turbulence is not conclusively linked to an increase.
Technological Advancements: Improved aircraft design and better turbulence prediction technologies may play a role in mitigating turbulence experiences, potentially skewing perceptions of increased turbulence incidents.
Confounding Factors: Weather patterns such as El Niño and La Niña significantly influence atmospheric conditions and can cause variations in turbulence independent of long-term climate trends.
Several recent high-profile turbulence incidents have been attributed to sudden atmospheric changes. For example, the severe turbulence encountered by Singapore Airlines flight SQ321 was likely caused by a combination of storm clouds and potentially clear air turbulence, both well-documented phenomena unrelated to long-term climate trends.
While the hypothesis linking climate change to increased turbulence is intriguing, it remains speculative without conclusive evidence. Turbulence is a multifaceted phenomenon influenced by a myriad of atmospheric conditions. The current scientific consensus does not definitively support the claim that climate change is making turbulence more frequent or severe. Future research must continue to unravel the complexities of atmospheric dynamics to provide a clearer picture. Until then, attributing turbulence directly to climate change remains a hypothesis rather than an established fact.
How Passengers Can Protect Themselves from Turbulence
Turbulence can be unsettling and, in some cases, dangerous. While pilots and airlines take numerous precautions to avoid turbulence, passengers can also take steps to protect themselves during flights. Here are some practical tips:
Always Wear Your Seatbelt: Keeping your seatbelt fastened at all times when seated is the most effective way to protect yourself from injury due to unexpected turbulence. Ensure the seatbelt is snug but comfortable, positioned low across your hips.
Follow Crew Instructions: Pay attention to announcements from the flight crew about expected turbulence. Follow all instructions regarding seatbelt use and remain seated when advised.
Choose Your Seat Wisely: Seats over the wings are generally the most stable part of the aircraft and experience less motion compared to seats at the front or back. While window seats offer better views, aisle seats can make it easier to get up and move around when safe to do so.
Secure Your Belongings: Store carry-on items in the overhead bin or under the seat in front of you to prevent them from becoming projectiles. Keep smaller items like books, laptops, and tablets secured when not in use.
Stay Informed About Weather: Before flying, check the weather conditions for your flight path. Apps and airline websites often provide turbulence forecasts. Don’t hesitate to ask flight attendants about the expected conditions if you’re concerned.
Use Seatback Pockets Sparingly: Avoid placing heavy or bulky items in the seatback pockets, as these can become hazards during turbulence. Ensure that any items you place in the pocket are secured.
Keep Calm and Breathe: Stay Relaxed! If turbulence occurs, try to remain calm. Use deep breathing techniques to manage anxiety. Understanding that turbulence is a normal part of flying can help reduce fear and anxiety.
Stay Hydrated and Avoid Alcohol: Drink plenty of water to stay hydrated, as dehydration can exacerbate feelings of discomfort and anxiety. Avoid excessive alcohol consumption, as it can impair your judgment and response to instructions.
Wear Appropriate Clothing: Wear comfortable, non-restrictive clothing to reduce discomfort during prolonged periods of turbulence.
Dressing in layers allows you to adjust to varying cabin temperatures, which can change during turbulence.
Use Safety Features: In the unlikely event that oxygen masks are deployed, secure your own mask before assisting others. Familiarize yourself with the location of emergency exits and safety procedures.
Consider Travel Insurance: Purchase travel insurance that covers flight delays and medical emergencies, providing peace of mind in case of turbulence-related incidents.
By following these tips, passengers can significantly reduce their risk of injury and increase their comfort during flights that encounter turbulence. Always prioritize safety and remain attentive to the guidance provided by the flight crew.
The fatal turbulence incident on Singapore Airlines flight SQ321 underscores the unpredictable nature of severe turbulence and the need for improved detection technologies. As airlines and researchers continue to seek solutions, passengers are reminded to always wear seat belts to minimize the risk of injury during unexpected turbulence.
Leave a Reply